The post at Barbaric Document on Paul Celan's complicity in Middle East injustice somehow offends.
Is the author unaware of the little pogrom in Poland after the war's end? That some 300,000 hid their identities and remain hidden?
That in the DP camps the western nations were complicit in the Zionist effort to redirect refugees to Palestine?
Where were they to go? Back home to Marburg? Evict the new tenants?
Where were they to go? Alexandria?
Stalin's little Jewish republic in the far east of the USSR?
Where were Polish Jews to go? Rumanian Jews (not yet "Romanian") ? Hide behind non-Jewish names, cover names which may never been their own?
Why was the state of Montana not their destination? Or Paraguay? Or Stalingrad?
Where is Galicia now? Where was the Swabian Jew to call home?
Some tried: Frank never reached his destination in Marburg. G. Husserl tried for some justice in Kiel.
And Sussana Ginzburg - a Ukranian Jew or a Polish Jew? Oh, I see, dead. Nationality irrelevant if the corpse was not found. And have I not mis-spelled her surname?
I have no answer: the borders of Europe were not about to dissolve; the Americans and Canadians did not want Jews. At least not ordinary Jews. Let alone Polish Jews. Ukrainian Jews. "Rumanian? [turns to his uniformed colleague] Rumanian - is that more like Serbian or more like Czech?"
Never underestimate the ignorance of an immigration bureaucrat.
Of course, by the 1950's the high north of Arctic Canada was in need of "inhabitants" to justify a "border" between Russians and Americans ... "Any of your Jews good at spearing walrus?" [Canada paid compensation to those victims but refused to apologize.]
They lured in aboriginals from the south - into canvas tents in the highest arctic with no moose - yes, walrus as moose.
And who all was complicit? Would a show trial or two help to clarify which artists are to be banned from the first union and relegated to the second or third artists' unions? Do we campaign to snatch back the Nobel Prize of Symborska?
Note: neither of my paternal great-grandfather nor my maternal grandfather seem to have set much store by the border known at the 49th parallel. My maternal great-grandfather may have ignored it and his father ended defending it while his maternal grandfather ignored it (while fearing the Sioux and preying on the Blackfoot ...)
When will I be invited back to claim my block of land or rock in the Orkney Islands? In the Jura. In Ireland. In Blackpool. Among the Swampy Cree of the rivers flowing into the western shore of whatever we will rename Hudson's Bay.
When will the Navajo south of Grants, NM, acknowledge me as a cousin and fit to share the water that I might view the pristine night sky above the ancient fields of lava of El Malpais?
And yet I share some of this - after learning of the deception Paul Ricoeur and his sometime colleague, Mircea Eliade.
Monday, May 30, 2011
Complicity of Celan in the Palestinian plight?
Labels:
Celan,
Heidegger,
Israel,
John Felstiner,
Palestine
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment